Skip to content
PlayOwl

What If? Lab

What if planets were not round?

All the planets are round, like balls. But many asteroids are lumpy, like potatoes! What if planets were not round? Let's find out with Olly.

Big worlds are round because gravity pulls everything toward the center from all sides. Small asteroids don't have enough gravity to do that, so most stay lumpy. Imagine a cube-shaped planet, meet the lumpy asteroids, and compare worlds to see how big something must be before gravity rounds it off.

The IAU's 2006 definition requires a planet to have enough mass for self-gravity to overcome rigid-body forces, giving a nearly round, hydrostatic equilibrium shape. Most asteroids remain irregular; Vesta, 530 km across, is almost spherical, and Ceres is round enough to count as a dwarf planet. This thought experiment asks what a non-round planet would mean.

Explore

The big question

Look at pictures of the planets. Every one is round!

Why aren't any shaped like cubes or pyramids? Let's find out.

The eight planets are very different. Some are small and rocky, some are giant balls of gas, some are close to the Sun and some are far away. But NASA points out that they're all round. None is shaped like a cube, a pyramid or a pancake.

So what if planets were not round? What would a cube-shaped planet be like, and why don't we find any? This is a thought experiment. Choose a path to find out how gravity makes balls, why asteroids are lumpy, and how big a world has to be before it turns round.

Roundness is part of what makes a planet. In 2006 the International Astronomical Union defined a planet as a body orbiting the Sun that has enough mass for its self-gravity to overcome rigid-body forces, so it takes a hydrostatic equilibrium, nearly round, shape, and that has cleared its orbital neighborhood.

This thought experiment asks what a non-round planet would imply. Evidence comes from NASA's measurements of planetary shapes and of asteroids and dwarf planets visited by spacecraft. Descriptions of life on a cube-shaped world are ideas from simple reasoning about gravity, not observations or model results.

Explore the idea

Make a prediction

Which is more likely to be lumpy?

Which is more likely to have a lumpy shape: a small asteroid or a big planet?

Which kind of body is less likely to be in hydrostatic equilibrium?

  • A small asteroid
  • A big planet
  • Both are always round
  • Established fact

    Gravity makes big worlds round.

    Gravity pulling toward the center from all sides makes planets round.

    Self-gravity drives large bodies into near-spherical equilibrium shapes (NASA, IAU).

  • Established fact

    Most asteroids are lumpy.

    Most asteroids are too small for gravity to make them round.

    Most asteroids are irregular (NASA).

  • An idea scientists discuss

    A box-shaped planet is pretend.

    A cube-shaped planet is an idea; gravity might turn it into a ball.

    The cube planet is a reasoning exercise, not a modeled or observed object.

  • Established fact

    Gravity pulls a planet into a ball.

    A planet's gravity pulls equally from all sides toward its center, which makes it a sphere.

    Gravity pulling equally toward the center gives planets their spherical shape (NASA Space Place).

  • Established fact

    Most asteroids are lumpy.

    Most asteroids have irregular shapes, though a few are nearly round.

    Most asteroids are irregularly shaped and often pitted or cratered (NASA).

  • Established fact

    A planet's gravity pulls like the spokes of a wheel.

    Gravity pulls from a planet's center to its edges like the spokes of a bicycle wheel, shaping it into a sphere.

    NASA likens planetary gravity to wheel spokes radiating from the center, producing a sphere.

  • Established fact

    To be a planet, a world must be big enough to be round.

    Scientists' definition of a planet says it must have enough gravity to pull itself into a nearly round shape.

    IAU 2006: a planet must have sufficient mass for self-gravity to overcome rigid-body forces, assuming a nearly round hydrostatic equilibrium shape (NASA).

  • An idea scientists discuss

    A box planet might slowly turn into a ball.

    If a planet started out shaped like a cube, gravity might crush its corners down until it became round.

    A planetary-mass cube might relax toward a sphere as corners yield under self-gravity; reasoning, not a model run.

  • Established fact

    Asteroid Bennu is small and made of rubble.

    Bennu is about one-third of a mile, or about half a kilometer, wide at its equator, and formed from leftover rubble.

    Bennu, ~one-third of a mile wide at the equator, coalesced from rubble 1–2 billion years ago (NASA).

  • Established fact

    Asteroid Eros is too small to be pulled into a ball.

    Asteroid Eros is about 32 kilometers long and shaped like a slipper. NASA says it is not massive enough for its own gravity to pull it into a round shape.

    Eros, a 20-mile (32 km) slipper-shaped asteroid, is not massive enough for its own gravity to have shaped it into a planet-like sphere (NASA APOD, 2000).

  • Established fact

    Some asteroids have their own little moons.

    More than 150 asteroids are known to have small moons, and some even have two.

    Over 150 asteroids have known companion moons; binary and triple systems also exist (NASA).

  • An idea scientists discuss

    On a lumpy asteroid, down might feel a bit tilted.

    On a lumpy asteroid, gravity might not pull straight down everywhere, so flat ground might feel a little like a slope.

    On an irregular body, local gravity might not be perpendicular to the surface, so level-looking ground might act as a slope; not quantified here.

  • Established fact

    Big Vesta is almost round.

    Vesta, the largest asteroid at about 530 kilometers across, is almost spherical, so it nearly counts as a dwarf planet.

    Vesta (~530 km) is almost spherical and nearly classified a dwarf planet; it is differentiated like Earth (NASA).

  • Established fact

    Ceres is round. It is a dwarf planet.

    Ceres, with a radius of 476 kilometers, is the largest object in the asteroid belt and a dwarf planet.

    Ceres, radius 476 km, is the asteroid belt's largest object and a dwarf planet, first visited by Dawn in 2015 (NASA).

  • Established fact

    Scientists argue about how round is round enough.

    Some scientists want to call any world a planet if gravity has made it roughly round. Others point out that this doesn't say how round is round enough, and distant shapes are hard to measure.

    Against a proposal to define a planet simply as a body massive enough to be roughly spherical, some scientists object that it leaves the needed degree of roundness unspecified, and distant objects' shapes are often hard to determine (NASA).

  • An idea scientists discuss

    Icy worlds and rocky worlds might turn round at different sizes.

    The size at which a world turns round might depend on what it's made of; the sources here don't give one size.

    The threshold might depend on composition and internal heat; no single size is given by the sources here.

Round, but not perfectly

Mercury and Venus are almost perfect balls.

Saturn and Jupiter spin fast, so they bulge a little around the middle.

NASA says Mercury and Venus are the roundest planets, nearly perfect spheres like marbles. Others are a bit squished. Fast-spinning Saturn is 10.7 percent wider around its middle than from pole to pole, and Jupiter is 6.9 percent wider.

Earth and Mars are much closer to round. Earth is only 0.3 percent wider at the middle, and Mars 0.6 percent. Uranus and Neptune are in between. That extra width at the middle is called the equatorial bulge.

NASA Space Place compares equatorial and polar diameters. Mercury and Venus are nearly perfect spheres. Saturn has the largest equatorial bulge, 10.7 percent, followed by Jupiter at 6.9 percent, Uranus at 2.3 percent and Neptune at 1.7 percent. Earth's bulge is 0.3 percent and Mars's 0.6 percent.

The bulge comes from rotation. Material at the equator moves fastest as a planet spins and tends to fling outward, while gravity holds it in; the balance leaves a slightly flattened sphere. Large, rapidly rotating gas giants flatten the most. NASA describes them as like basketballs squashed by someone sitting on them, while Earth and Mars, smaller and slower, stay within one percent of round.

Build a cube planet

Imagine a planet shaped like a giant box. The corners would stick out far from the middle.

Gravity pulls toward the middle. So the corners might slowly slump down, and the box might turn into a ball!

Imagine a planet shaped like a giant cube. Its corners would be much farther from the center than the middle of each flat side. Gravity pulls everything toward the center, so walking from the middle of a face toward a corner might feel like climbing a huge hill.

For a big world, that pull might be strong enough to crush the corners down. Over time, a cube planet might slump into a ball. These are ideas from thinking about gravity, not something scientists have seen.

On a cube of planetary mass, the corners would lie about 1.7 times as far from the center as the face centers, since a cube's corner-to-center distance is √3 times its half-width. Gravity pulling toward the center might make the faces behave like enormous slopes running downhill toward their middles.

If the body were massive enough to be a planet, its self-gravity would, by the IAU's criterion, overcome the rock's rigid strength, so the corners might yield and flow until the shape approached a sphere. So a lasting cube-shaped planet might not be possible; the scenario is an idea used to show why mass and roundness go together.

Why gravity makes balls

Gravity pulls things together. A planet's gravity pulls from its center, the same in every direction.

That pull squeezes the planet into a round ball.

Planets form when bits of material in space bump and clump together. NASA explains that once a clump has enough material, its gravity gets strong. A planet's gravity pulls equally from all sides toward its center, like the spokes of a bicycle wheel.

That makes the overall shape a sphere, a three-dimensional circle. Smaller objects can be different: NASA says asteroid Eros, about 32 kilometers long, is not massive enough for its own gravity to have pulled it into a ball, so it keeps its odd slipper shape.

Gravity pulls toward a body's center from every direction, which NASA likens to the spokes of a wheel. In the IAU's words, a body massive enough for its self-gravity to overcome rigid-body forces assumes a hydrostatic equilibrium, nearly round, shape. Rotation then adds a slight flattening, as the equatorial bulges NASA lists show.

Small bodies fall short of that: NASA notes that Eros, a 20-mile (32 km) slipper-shaped asteroid, is not massive enough for its own gravity to have shaped it into a planet-like sphere. Where the line falls is not settled. NASA reports that when some scientists suggest defining a planet simply as a body massive enough to be roughly spherical, others object that this does not say what degree of roundness is needed, and that the shapes of distant objects are often hard to measure.

From lumpy to round

Most asteroids are lumpy. Big Vesta is almost round. Bigger Ceres is round!

Big worlds have enough gravity to pull themselves round.

NASA says most asteroids are irregular, lumpy shapes, though a few are nearly round. Asteroid Bennu, visited by NASA's OSIRIS-REx, is only about half a kilometer wide, formed from rubble and looks like a spinning top.

Vesta, the largest asteroid at about 530 kilometers across, is almost spherical, so it nearly counts as a dwarf planet. Ceres, with a radius of 476 kilometers, is the largest object in the asteroid belt and is a dwarf planet: big enough for gravity to make it round. NASA's Dawn spacecraft visited both.

Shape tracks size and mass. Most asteroids are irregular and often pitted; Bennu, about one-third of a mile wide at its equator, coalesced from leftover rubble 1 to 2 billion years ago and is shaped like a spinning top, a shape whose origin NASA says scientists don't fully understand. Vesta, about 530 km across, accounts for almost 9 percent of the total mass of all asteroids, is differentiated into crust, mantle and core, and is almost spherical, nearly a dwarf planet; a giant impact left the Rheasilvia crater, about 95 percent of its mean diameter.

Ceres, radius 476 km and the belt's largest object, meets the dwarf-planet criterion of a hydrostatic equilibrium shape. NASA's Dawn orbited Vesta in 2011 and 2012 and reached Ceres in 2015.

Amazing facts

  • All the asteroids together weigh less than our Moon.

    If you put all the asteroids together, their total mass would be less than that of Earth's Moon.

    The combined mass of all asteroids is less than the Moon's (NASA).

  • Ceres spins around very fast.

    A day on Ceres lasts only about 9 hours, one of the shortest days in the solar system.

    Ceres rotates every 9 hours, among the shortest days in the solar system (NASA).

  • Vesta has a giant crater almost as wide as Vesta itself!

    Vesta's Rheasilvia crater is about 500 kilometers wide, some 95 percent of the asteroid's average width.

    Rheasilvia, ~500 km across (95% of Vesta's mean diameter), formed in a collision that removed about 1% of Vesta's mass (NASA).

  • You can feel what a spinning planet feels!

    Spin around with your arms out and you'll feel your hands pulled outward, like a planet's bulging middle.

    NASA Space Place suggests spinning with arms out to feel why equatorial material is flung outward.

Words to know

sphere
a perfectly round ball shape
gravity
the pull that every object has on every other object
asteroid
a rocky object, smaller than a planet, that orbits the Sun
dwarf planet
a round world that orbits the Sun but has not cleared its path of other objects
equatorial bulge
the extra width around a spinning planet's middle
hydrostatic equilibrium
the nearly round shape a big world settles into when its gravity is stronger than its rock

Discovery challenge

  1. What makes planets round?

    What makes planets round?

    What force gives planets their near-spherical shape?

    • Gravity pulling toward the center
    • Wind smoothing them
    • Spinning makes them perfect balls
    Show the answer

    Gravity pulling toward the center

    Gravity, pulling from every side!

    Gravity pulls equally from all sides toward the center. Spinning actually makes them bulge.

    Self-gravity; rotation causes oblateness, not roundness.

  2. Which planet bulges most around its middle?

    Which planet has the biggest bulge around its middle?

    Which planet has the largest equatorial bulge?

    • Saturn
    • Mercury
    • Earth
    Show the answer

    Saturn

    Saturn!

    Saturn, 10.7 percent wider at its middle.

    Saturn, at 10.7 percent.

  3. What shape are most asteroids?

    What shape are most asteroids?

    Which shape description fits most asteroids, according to NASA?

    • Lumpy and irregular
    • Perfect balls
    • Flat like pancakes
    Show the answer

    Lumpy and irregular

    Lumpy, like potatoes!

    Lumpy and irregular, because their gravity is too weak to pull them round.

    Irregular, often pitted or cratered.

Experiments to try

Explore next

For parents & teachers

What children will learn

  • Gravity pulls equally toward a big world's center, making it round.
  • Spinning planets bulge a little around the middle.
  • Small asteroids have weak gravity and stay lumpy; larger bodies like Ceres are round.
  • A cube-shaped planet is an idea used to explain why planets are round.

Recommended ages: 7 to 17 ยท About 12 minutes

Talk about it

  • Why do you think size matters for whether a world is round?
  • What would be strange about walking on a cube-shaped planet?
  • Which cards in this lab were facts, and which were ideas?

Try at home or in class

  • Squeeze a lump of play dough evenly from all sides with both hands and see it become rounder, like gravity pulling from every direction.
  • Spin around safely with your arms out, then pull them in, and feel the outward pull NASA describes for a spinning planet's middle.

Key vocabulary: sphere, gravity, asteroid, dwarf planet, equatorial bulge, hydrostatic equilibrium

Where these facts come from

  1. Why Are Planets Round? , NASA Space Place
  2. What Is a Planet? , NASA Science
  3. Asteroids: Facts , NASA Science
  4. 4 Vesta , NASA Science
  5. Ceres: Facts , NASA Science
  6. 101955 Bennu , NASA Science
  7. Bennu: Facts , NASA Science
  8. APOD: 2000 February 16 - Eros From Orbit , NASA Astronomy Picture of the Day

Checked, not yet human-reviewed. Last updated October 24, 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.