What If? Lab
What if a city had no trees?
Trees give shade on hot days and homes to birds. What if a city had no trees at all? Let's walk down Olly's street and imagine!
Cities are full of roads, roofs and parking lots that soak up the Sun's heat. Street trees shade them, cool the air, catch rain and give birds a home. Imagine a city with every tree gone: hotter streets, more rain rushing down the drains and fewer birds. Then see how people plant trees to help.
Urban surfaces absorb and re-emit more solar heat than natural landscapes, creating heat islands. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency reports that trees cool cities through shade and evapotranspiration, intercept 15 to 27 percent of annual rainfall, filter pollutants and provide habitat. Removing them would remove each of these services.
The big question
Look down a city street. You might see trees along the sidewalk and in the park.
What if all of those trees were gone? Would the city feel different?
Most cities have trees: along streets, in parks, in schoolyards and backyards. It is easy to think of them as decoration. But trees quietly do several jobs for a city every day.
This lab is a thought experiment. Imagine a city where every tree has been taken away. What would change on a hot summer day, during a rainstorm, and for the birds and people who live there? Choose a path to find out.
Urban trees provide what ecologists call ecosystem services: cooling, stormwater interception, air filtering, energy savings and wildlife habitat. These are measured in cities today, so we can reason about a treeless city from real data.
This thought experiment removes the whole urban tree canopy and asks which services disappear, how big each one is according to the EPA's summaries of research, and what cities do to keep or grow their canopy.
Explore the idea
Make a prediction
If a city had no trees, how would a sunny street feel?
On a sunny summer day, how would a city with no trees compare with one full of trees?
With the urban canopy removed, what would happen to the city's heat island?
- Hotter
- Cooler
- Exactly the same
-
Established fact
Roads and roofs soak up the Sun's heat.
Buildings, roads and parking lots soak up and give off more of the Sun's heat than forests and water.
Urban infrastructure absorbs and re-emits more solar heat than natural landscapes, forming heat islands (EPA).
-
An idea scientists discuss
A city with no trees is pretend. We use real facts about trees to imagine it.
No real city has lost every tree; this thought experiment uses measured benefits of trees to imagine what would change.
Outcomes for a fully treeless city are inferred from measured per-tree and per-area benefits, not observed directly.
-
Established fact
Trees cool the air with their shade.
Trees lower air and ground temperatures by giving shade and by evaporating water from their leaves.
Vegetation lowers surface and air temperatures through shade and evapotranspiration (EPA).
-
Established fact
Cities are often warmer than the countryside.
In the United States, cities are about 1 to 7 °F warmer than the areas around them in the daytime, and about 2 to 5 °F warmer at night.
U.S. urban heat islands: daytime about 1–7 °F, nighttime about 2–5 °F above outlying areas (EPA review).
-
Established fact
Places with trees are cooler.
A review of 308 studies found city forests were on average 3 °F cooler than city areas without greenery.
A review of 308 studies found urban forests averaged 3.0 °F (1.6 °C) cooler than urban non-green areas.
-
An idea scientists discuss
A city with no trees would probably feel hotter.
A city with no trees would probably be hotter, especially on sunny, still days, though nobody has measured a whole treeless city.
Removing the whole canopy would likely push temperatures toward the hot end of heat-island ranges; no source quantifies a fully treeless city.
-
Established fact
Trees soak up some of the rain.
City trees can reduce runoff by soaking up 15 to 27 percent of the rain that falls each year.
Urban trees can reduce stormwater runoff by absorbing 15–27 percent of annual rainfall (EPA).
-
Established fact
Trees help keep dirty water out of streams.
Trees and plants filter fertilizers, pesticides and other pollution that would otherwise wash off pavement into streams and lakes.
Vegetation filters fertilizers, pesticides, animal waste and other pollutants that readily run off paved surfaces during storms.
-
An idea scientists discuss
With no trees, storm drains might fill up faster.
With no trees, storm drains might fill faster in heavy rain, and streets might flood more often.
Higher runoff volumes might overload drainage in intense storms; the size of the effect would depend on each city's drains and soils.
-
Established fact
Trees are homes for birds, bats and squirrels.
City trees give homes and food to pollinating insects, migrating birds, bats and squirrels.
Urban trees and vegetation provide habitat and food for pollinators, migratory birds and small mammals (EPA).
-
Established fact
People can plant trees to help.
When planting trees, choose kinds that suit the local climate, plant them in the right place and look after them while they are young.
EPA planting guidance: climate-suited species, placement (deciduous trees to the west cool buildings most), early maintenance, native species.
-
An idea scientists discuss
A city with no trees would be quieter, with fewer birds singing.
A city with no trees would likely have far fewer birds, bats and squirrels, because they would lose their homes and food.
Wildlife dependent on canopy habitat would likely decline sharply in a treeless city; the extent would vary by species.
A city with trees
On a hot day, trees make cool shade. You can rest under them.
When it rains, tree leaves catch some of the raindrops. Birds and squirrels live in the branches.
Trees cool a city in two ways. Their leaves shade the ground and buildings. They also drink water through their roots and let it evaporate from their leaves, which takes heat from the air. This is called evapotranspiration.
Trees catch rain on their leaves and soak it up, so less water rushes off roofs and streets. They trap some pollution on their leaves, and they give homes and food to insects, birds, bats and squirrels.
The EPA describes two cooling mechanisms: shade, and evapotranspiration, in which trees draw water through their roots and evaporate it from their leaves, using heat from the air. One review of 308 studies found urban forests were on average 3.0 °F (1.6 °C) cooler than non-green urban areas.
Urban trees can absorb 15 to 27 percent of annual rainfall, reducing runoff; they filter fertilizers, pesticides and other pollutants; pollutants such as particulates, nitrogen oxides and ozone deposit on their leaves; and shading buildings cuts air-conditioning demand.
Take the trees away
Now imagine Olly's city with no trees. There is no shade on the sidewalk. The streets feel hotter.
When it rains, more water rushes along the street to the drains. The birds have fewer places to rest.
Without trees, the Sun would beat down on roads, roofs and parking lots. These hard surfaces soak up heat and give it off slowly, even after sunset. A city already tends to be warmer than the countryside around it, and losing its trees would remove one of its best ways to cool down.
Rain would land on hard surfaces instead of leaves and soil, so more of it would run into storm drains and streams, carrying pollution with it. Birds, bats and squirrels would lose their homes.
Buildings, roads and other infrastructure absorb and re-emit more of the Sun's heat than forests or water. In the United States, heat islands raise urban daytime temperatures about 1–7 °F and nighttime temperatures about 2–5 °F above outlying areas, and conventional roofing can reach 66 °F above the surrounding air on warm days.
Removing the canopy would remove shade and evapotranspiration, and with them the cooler pockets that urban forests create; the rainfall trees intercept would become runoff, and the habitat they provide would vanish. Exact numbers for a whole city without trees are not something the sources give.
Why trees matter
Trees work like a big umbrella and a sponge.
They block the Sun, cool the air and soak up rain. Without them, the city gets hotter and wetter streets.
Dark, hard surfaces like asphalt and many roofs reflect less sunlight and store more heat than plants and soil. Trees are different: they shade those surfaces and use the Sun's energy to evaporate water, which cools the air around them.
Trees also slow down rain. Leaves catch drops, and trees soak up some of the water, so less rushes off the pavement. Each of these jobs is small for one tree, but a whole city's trees add up.
Conventional paving and roofing reflect less solar energy and absorb and emit more heat than vegetation, and dense urban geometry traps heat and blocks cooling winds. Heat islands often become more pronounced after sunset as materials slowly release stored heat.
Trees counter this with shade, latent cooling and interception. The EPA's figures are averages from research and vary with climate, species and placement: in a desert city, for example, trees must be species suited to hot, dry conditions, and placement matters for how much a building is cooled.
Growing city forests
Many cities plant new trees every year. Neighbors and kids can help!
Young trees need water and care, so people look after them as they grow.
Cities and neighbors plant trees to cool streets and catch rain. The EPA advises choosing trees that suit the local climate, planting them in the right place (trees on the west side of a building help cool it most), and caring for them while they are young.
Native species usually need less care. More tree cover is also linked to fewer heat illnesses such as heat stroke, so planting trees helps people as well as birds.
EPA guidance for community tree planting stresses species suited to the local climate, careful placement (deciduous trees or vines to the west are most effective for cooling a building), early maintenance that declines over time, native species to lower costs, and avoiding utilities and sidewalks.
The EPA links greater tree cover to fewer heat illnesses and fewer heat-related deaths in cities, and notes that green infrastructure can cut nearby buildings' energy demand by about 10 percent. These are reasons many cities run canopy programs today.
Amazing facts
-
A roof in the sun can get much hotter than the air.
On a warm day, an ordinary roof can be as much as 66 °F hotter than the air around it.
Conventional roofing materials can reach up to 66 °F above surrounding air temperatures on warm days (EPA).
-
Trees catch dust and dirt from the air on their leaves.
Tiny bits of air pollution stick to tree leaves, and tall, thick roadside plants can cut pollution downwind by about 30 percent.
Particulates, NOx, SO₂, CO and ozone deposit on leaves; tall, dense roadside vegetation can lower downwind pollutants by about 30 percent.
-
City parks and ponds are cool spots.
Even inside a city, parks and ponds are cooler than downtown streets, making cool islands in the heat.
Intra-urban temperature differences mean parks, ponds and residential areas are typically cooler than dense downtowns.
Words to know
- heat island
- a city area that is warmer than the land around it because of roads, roofs and buildings
- evapotranspiration
- water moving from the ground through plants and into the air, which cools the air
- runoff
- rainwater that flows over the ground instead of soaking in
- canopy
- the layer of leaves and branches formed by trees
- storm drain
- an opening in a street that carries rainwater away
- native species
- a plant or animal that naturally belongs in a place
Discovery challenge
-
How do trees cool a hot street?
Which two ways do trees cool a city?
Which two mechanisms do trees use to lower urban temperatures?
- Shade and evaporating water from leaves
- Wind and snow
- Making the Sun smaller
Show the answer
Shade and evaporating water from leaves
They make shade, and water leaves their leaves into the air.
Shade, and evapotranspiration: water drawn up by roots evaporates from leaves and takes heat from the air.
Shading and evapotranspiration, which uses heat from the air to evaporate water.
-
Where does more rain go if there are no trees?
Without trees, where would more of a city's rain go?
Without canopy interception, where would more urban rainfall end up?
- Down the street into storm drains
- Into the trees
- Up into space
Show the answer
Down the street into storm drains
It runs down the street into the drains.
More would run off roofs and roads into storm drains; trees can soak up 15 to 27 percent of yearly rain.
Stormwater runoff; trees otherwise intercept 15–27 percent of annual rainfall.
-
Are cities warmer or cooler than the countryside?
In the United States, how do city daytime temperatures compare with the areas around them?
Compared with outlying areas, the EPA reports that U.S. urban daytime temperatures are…
- Warmer
- Cooler
- Always the same
Show the answer
Warmer
Warmer. Roads and roofs soak up the Sun.
Warmer, by about 1 to 7 °F in the daytime.
Warmer: about 1–7 °F by day and 2–5 °F at night.
-
Which animal lives in city trees?
Which of these animals depends on city trees for a home?
Which group does the EPA list among species supported by urban trees?
- Squirrels
- Sharks
- Camels
Show the answer
Squirrels
Squirrels live in trees, and so do many birds.
Squirrels, along with bats, birds and insects.
Small mammals such as squirrels and bats, plus pollinators and migratory birds.
Experiments to try
- Watch What If? Lab What if all trees disappeared? Trees take in carbon dioxide and store carbon in their wood, put water into the air, hold soil in place and give homes to most kinds of land animals. Follow what would happen without them, and find out why the ocean still makes about half of our oxygen.
- Watch What If? Lab What if a river changed its course? A winding river wears away the outside of each bend and piles sand on the inside, so slowly, year by year, it moves. Sometimes it cuts off a loop and leaves a lake behind. Imagine a big river changing its course: what would happen to the old loops, and to the towns and bridges beside it?
- Watch What If? Lab What if a rainforest had little rain? Rainforests are tall, green forests that get a great deal of rain. In 2005 and 2010, big droughts hit the Amazon rainforest, and satellites watched what happened to its trees. Use those real events to imagine a rainforest with little rain: drier leaves, hungry animals and a forest that might change.
- Watch What If? Lab What if every roof grew food? Most city roofs are bare, but some already grow lettuce, tomatoes and herbs, in boxes of soil or in water with no soil at all. Imagine every roof growing food. How would the plants get light and water up there? How much food could a city grow on top of itself? Explore what real rooftop farms have shown, and what they cost.
- Watch What If? Lab What if pollution disappeared from cities? Vehicles, factories and other sources can put pollution into city air. Since 1970, EPA says total emissions of six main air pollutants in the United States have dropped by 78 percent, and cities such as Beijing have cut their pollution too. Imagine city air with no pollution at all, and follow what might change.
Explore next
- Watch What If? Lab What if all trees disappeared? Trees take in carbon dioxide and store carbon in their wood, put water into the air, hold soil in place and give homes to most kinds of land animals. Follow what would happen without them, and find out why the ocean still makes about half of our oxygen.
- Watch What If? Lab What if a river changed its course? A winding river wears away the outside of each bend and piles sand on the inside, so slowly, year by year, it moves. Sometimes it cuts off a loop and leaves a lake behind. Imagine a big river changing its course: what would happen to the old loops, and to the towns and bridges beside it?
- Watch What If? Lab What if a rainforest had little rain? Rainforests are tall, green forests that get a great deal of rain. In 2005 and 2010, big droughts hit the Amazon rainforest, and satellites watched what happened to its trees. Use those real events to imagine a rainforest with little rain: drier leaves, hungry animals and a forest that might change.
-
Watch
3D
Animal
Eastern gray squirrel
Eastern gray squirrels are bushy-tailed tree squirrels from the forests of eastern North America, and they are a common sight in parks and gardens. They bury nuts to eat later. People also took them to Britain and other countries; in Britain they cause problems for the native red squirrel.
- Watch What If? Lab What if every roof grew food? Most city roofs are bare, but some already grow lettuce, tomatoes and herbs, in boxes of soil or in water with no soil at all. Imagine every roof growing food. How would the plants get light and water up there? How much food could a city grow on top of itself? Explore what real rooftop farms have shown, and what they cost.
- Watch What If? Lab What if pollution disappeared from cities? Vehicles, factories and other sources can put pollution into city air. Since 1970, EPA says total emissions of six main air pollutants in the United States have dropped by 78 percent, and cities such as Beijing have cut their pollution too. Imagine city air with no pollution at all, and follow what might change.
- Watch Geography Villages, towns and cities A place where people live together is called a settlement. A village is a small settlement, often in the countryside. A town is bigger than a village but smaller than a city. A city is a large place with many people, buildings, roads and jobs. In 2025, the United Nations reported that 45 percent of the world's people live in cities.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if Earth had no atmosphere? Earth's air works like a jacket: it keeps heat in and carries it around. Take the air away in our model of a sandy patch of ground on the equator, and the coldest part of the night drops from about 13 °C to about 2 °C.
For parents & teachers
What children will learn
- City surfaces like roads and roofs absorb heat, making cities warmer than their surroundings.
- Trees cool cities through shade and evapotranspiration, and soak up rain.
- Trees provide homes and food for wildlife and support people's health.
- Communities plant and care for trees, choosing kinds that suit their climate.
Recommended ages: 5 to 17 · About 15 minutes
Talk about it
- Where is the coolest spot near your home or school on a sunny day? Why?
- Where does rain go after it falls on your street?
- If your class could plant one tree, where would it do the most good?
Try at home or in class
- On a sunny day, put your hand (briefly) on a sunny sidewalk, a shaded sidewalk and grass under a tree, or use an outdoor thermometer, and compare.
- Pour a cup of water onto pavement and another onto soil or grass, and watch where each one goes.
Key vocabulary: heat island, evapotranspiration, runoff, canopy, storm drain, native species
Where these facts come from
- Benefits of Trees and Vegetation , U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
- What Are Heat Islands? , U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
- Community Member Tree Planting Efforts , U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Checked, not yet human-reviewed. Last updated October 23, 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.