What If? Lab
What if a comet passed close to Earth?
A comet is a big ball of ice and dust. When it comes near the Sun, it grows a glowing tail! What if one passed close to Earth? Let's watch with Olly.
Comets are icy leftovers from when our solar system formed. Near the Sun, they warm up and grow a glowing cloud and long tails. Dust they leave behind gives us meteor showers. Astronomers have predicted comets' returns for centuries: Halley's Comet is due back in 2061.
A comet's nucleus, often a few miles across, is ice, frozen gas and dust. Solar heating builds a coma up to hundreds of thousands of kilometers wide, and sunlight and the solar wind push out dust and ion tails. Debris trails produce annual meteor showers, and orbits are computed far ahead, as Edmond Halley first showed in 1705.
The big question
Sometimes a comet shows up in the night sky. It looks like a fuzzy star with a long tail.
What is a comet? And what if one passed close by Earth?
Every so often, a comet appears in the night sky as a fuzzy patch of light, sometimes with a long, glowing tail. NASA explains that people long ago were awed by comets, which seemed to appear without warning.
Today, scientists know what comets are and how they move. So what would we see if a comet passed close to Earth? What would it leave behind? And how do astronomers know where comets are going? This is a thought experiment built on what scientists know. Choose a path and explore.
Comets are, in NASA's words, leftovers from the dawn of our solar system. Short-period comets, with orbits under 200 years, often return predictably; long-period comets, many from the distant Oort Cloud, can take as long as 30 million years per orbit.
This thought experiment follows a comet passing near Earth: how its coma and tails form, what its debris does, and how astronomers compute and follow comet orbits. Facts come from NASA; anything about a particular imagined comet is labeled as an idea, and the lab makes no predictions about real ones.
Explore the idea
Make a prediction
Which way does a comet's tail point?
When a comet nears the Sun, which way do its tails point?
Relative to the Sun, which way do a comet's tails point?
- Away from the Sun
- Toward the Sun
- Always toward Earth
-
Established fact
Comets grow tails when they come near the Sun.
Near the Sun, a comet's ices turn to gas, forming a coma and tails pushed away from the Sun.
Solar heating, radiation pressure and the solar wind form a comet's coma and tails (NASA).
-
An idea scientists discuss
This is a pretend comet.
This lab imagines one comet passing near Earth using real comet science; what our pretend comet would do is an idea.
The comet is imagined; its appearance and any future meteor shower are ideas, not predictions.
-
Established fact
A comet's middle is a lump of ice and dust.
A comet's nucleus is often a few miles across, made of icy chunks and frozen gases with bits of dust.
The nucleus, often a few miles across, contains icy chunks and frozen gases with embedded dust (NASA).
-
Established fact
Comets are leftovers from long ago.
Comets are leftovers from the dawn of our solar system, about 4.6 billion years ago.
Comets are leftovers from the formation of the solar system (NASA).
-
Established fact
Near the Sun, a comet grows a glowing cloud.
The Sun's heat turns a comet's ices into gas, building a coma that can stretch hundreds of thousands of kilometers.
Solar heating converts ices to gas; the coma may extend hundreds of thousands of kilometers (NASA).
-
Established fact
Comets have two tails.
Sunlight and the solar wind blow a comet's dust and gas away from the Sun into two tails: a dust tail and a gas tail.
Radiation pressure and the solar wind form a dust tail and an ion (gas) tail (NASA).
-
An idea scientists discuss
A comet passing near Earth might look big and bright.
A comet passing near Earth might look large and bright in the night sky, though how bright would depend on the comet.
A close approach might make a comet appear large and bright; its actual appearance would depend on its size and activity.
-
Established fact
Meteor showers come from comet dust.
Some meteor showers happen every year as Earth passes through the trail of dusty debris left by a comet.
Meteor showers occur annually or at regular intervals as Earth passes through comet debris trails (NASA).
-
Established fact
Every Perseid shooting star is a tiny bit of a comet.
Every Perseid meteor, peaking around August 12, is a tiny piece of Comet Swift-Tuttle, which passes the Sun every 135 years.
Every Perseid is a fragment of Comet Swift-Tuttle (135-year period); the Orionids, in October, come from Halley's Comet (NASA).
-
An idea scientists discuss
Our comet might give us shooting stars later.
If Earth's path crossed our imagined comet's dusty trail, it might bring a meteor shower in later years.
An imagined comet might seed a future shower only if its debris intersects Earth's orbit; that cannot be assumed.
-
Established fact
Edmond Halley correctly said when a comet would come back.
In 1705, Edmond Halley predicted that a comet would return in 1758; it did, and it is now called Halley's Comet.
Halley's 1705 calculations correctly predicted the 1758 return, the first such prediction (NASA).
-
Established fact
Halley's Comet will be back in 2061.
Halley's Comet was last seen from Earth in 1986 and will return in 2061, on its 76-year trip around the Sun.
Halley's Comet, last seen in 1986, returns in 2061 on its roughly 76-year orbit (NASA).
-
Established fact
Scientists at NASA keep watch on comets.
NASA's Planetary Defense Coordination Office, set up in 2016, finds and tracks asteroids and comets that come near Earth.
Established in 2016, NASA's PDCO finds, tracks and studies near-Earth asteroids and comets (NASA).
A frozen visitor
Far from the Sun, a comet is a frozen lump of ice, gas and dust. It has no tail at all.
It travels on a long path around the Sun.
Far from the Sun, a comet is just its frozen center, called the nucleus. NASA says a nucleus is often a few miles across and is made of icy chunks and frozen gases with bits of dust mixed in.
Many comets come from an icy belt beyond Neptune, where Pluto orbits, or from a far more distant region called the Oort Cloud. Every so often, gravity nudges one onto a path that brings it into the inner solar system, closer to the Sun.
A comet's nucleus, often a few miles across, holds icy chunks and frozen gases with embedded dust (NASA). Short-period comets come from the Kuiper Belt beyond Neptune, a disc of icy bodies theorized by Gerard Kuiper in 1951; long-period comets, many from the Oort Cloud about 100,000 astronomical units out, can take up to 30 million years to orbit.
Gravity occasionally pushes Kuiper Belt objects onto orbits that bring them closer to the Sun, and they become short-period comets; many of these return predictably because they have passed by before.
A comet comes close
As the comet gets near the Sun, it warms up. Some of its ice turns into gas.
The gas and dust make a glowing cloud and a long tail. What a sight!
As a comet nears the Sun, NASA explains, the Sun's heat turns some of its ice into gas, building a fuzzy atmosphere called the coma that can stretch hundreds of thousands of kilometers. Sunlight and a stream of fast particles from the Sun, the solar wind, push the dust and gas away from the Sun, sometimes making a long, bright tail.
Comets actually have two tails, one of dust and one of gas. If a comet passed close to Earth, it might look big and bright in our sky for a while, before heading back out into space.
Solar heating sublimates the nucleus's ices, so the coma grows; NASA notes it may extend hundreds of thousands of kilometers. Radiation pressure and the solar wind blow coma dust and gas away from the Sun, forming a dust tail and an ion (gas) tail, both blown away from the Sun.
How a passing comet would look from Earth would depend on its size, its activity and its distance, which is why the lab's view of a close comet is an idea. Some comets, called sungrazers, fly so close to the Sun that they break up and evaporate.
Why comets leave meteor showers
A comet drops bits of dust along its path, like crumbs.
When Earth passes through the crumbs, they zip into our air and glow. That's a meteor shower!
As a comet travels, it sheds dust and rock that spread out along its path. NASA explains that when Earth passes through one of these dusty trails, the bits rush into our atmosphere and burn up as meteors, or shooting stars. Lots of them at once make a meteor shower.
Some meteor showers happen every year, as Earth passes through the same dusty trails again. The Perseids, which peak around August 12, are tiny pieces of Comet Swift-Tuttle.
Meteoroids are pieces of larger bodies; some come from comets. NASA explains that meteor showers occur annually or at regular intervals as Earth passes through the trail of dusty debris left by a comet (and, in a few cases, asteroids). Every Perseid meteor is a piece of Comet Swift-Tuttle, which passes the Sun every 135 years; the Leonids come from Comet Tempel-Tuttle; and Halley's debris gives the Eta Aquarids in May and the Orionids in October.
Whether a newly passing comet would produce a shower later depends on whether Earth's orbit ever crosses its debris; for an imagined comet, that is an idea, not a prediction.
How astronomers track comets
Long ago, a scientist named Edmond Halley worked out when a comet would come back. He was right!
Today, scientists at NASA keep watch on comets and work out their paths.
In 1705, astronomer Edmond Halley used Isaac Newton's ideas about gravity to work out the paths of comets. He noticed that bright comets seen in 1531, 1607 and 1682 had very similar paths, and suggested they were one comet coming back again and again. He predicted it would return in 1758, and it did. It was named Halley's Comet, and NASA says it will return in 2061.
Today, NASA's Planetary Defense Coordination Office, set up in 2016, finds and tracks asteroids and comets that come near Earth.
Halley's 1705 orbit calculations, based on Newton's gravitation, linked the comets of 1531, 1607 and 1682 into one returning object and correctly predicted its 1758 return: the first such prediction, NASA notes. Halley's Comet was last seen from Earth in 1986, when an international fleet of spacecraft met it, and will return in 2061 on its roughly 76-year orbit.
In 2016 NASA established the Planetary Defense Coordination Office to find, track and better understand asteroids and comets that could pose an impact hazard to Earth. Its planned NEO Surveyor telescope is designed to help find most of the potentially hazardous asteroids and comets that come within 30 million miles of Earth.
Amazing facts
-
Halley's Comet comes back about every 76 years.
Halley's Comet returns about every 76 years; it was last seen in 1986 and will be back in 2061.
Halley's orbital period is about 76.1 years; it has been in its present orbit for at least 16,000 years (NASA).
-
Shooting stars in October can be crumbs from Halley's Comet.
The Orionid meteor shower each October, and the Eta Aquarids each May, come from dust left by Halley's Comet.
Each return of Halley sprays ice and rock into space, producing two weak annual showers, the Eta Aquarids (May) and Orionids (October) (NASA).
-
Lots of space dust lands on Earth every day.
Scientists estimate that about 44,000 kilograms of meteoritic material falls on Earth each day.
About 48.5 tons (44,000 kg) of meteoritic material is estimated to fall on Earth daily (NASA).
Words to know
- comet
- an icy object that orbits the Sun and grows a glowing cloud and tails when it gets close
- nucleus
- the solid, frozen center of a comet
- coma
- the fuzzy cloud of gas and dust around a comet's nucleus
- meteor shower
- many shooting stars seen when Earth passes through a trail of comet dust
- orbit
- the path an object follows around the Sun or a planet
Discovery challenge
-
What is a comet made of?
What is a comet's nucleus made of?
What makes up a comet's nucleus?
- Ice, frozen gas and dust
- Hot melted rock
- Only metal
Show the answer
Ice, frozen gas and dust
Ice, frozen gas and dust.
Icy chunks and frozen gases with bits of dust mixed in.
Icy chunks and frozen gases with embedded dust.
-
Which way does a comet's tail point?
Which way do a comet's tails point?
Relative to the Sun, which way do a comet's tails point?
- Away from the Sun
- Toward the Sun
- Always toward Earth
Show the answer
Away from the Sun
Away from the Sun. The Sun's light and wind push it.
Away from the Sun: sunlight and the solar wind push the dust and gas.
Away from the Sun: radiation pressure and the solar wind drive the tails away from it.
-
Where do meteor showers come from?
What causes most meteor showers?
What produces recurring meteor showers?
- Earth passing through comet dust
- Stars falling from the sky
- Lightning in space
Show the answer
Earth passing through comet dust
From comet dust burning up in our air.
Earth passing through the dusty trail left by a comet.
Earth crossing comet debris trails; the Perseids come from Swift-Tuttle.
Experiments to try
- Watch What If? Lab What if meteor showers happened every night? A few shooting stars streak across any clear night sky, but during a meteor shower you might see dozens an hour. Showers happen when Earth passes through dust left by a comet, which is why they come back on the same dates every year. Imagine a shower every night, and find out what that would take.
- Watch What If? Lab What if you could ride a comet? A comet's center is a dusty ball of ice a few kilometers across, racing around the Sun. In 2014, the European Space Agency's Philae lander touched down on comet 67P, and because the comet's gravity is so weak, it bounced! Imagine riding a comet, then see what a real spacecraft found.
- Watch What If? Lab What if an asteroid struck the Moon? The Moon's craters are a record of space rocks landing over billions of years, and small ones still land there every day. Scientists watch for tiny flashes of light on the Moon and later find the brand-new craters. Explore what happens when a rock hits the Moon, and why the Moon keeps going around Earth as always.
- Watch What If? Lab What if the Sun had no sunspots? Sunspots are darker, cooler patches on the Sun made by strong magnetic fields, and their numbers rise and fall about every 11 years. Imagine a Sun with none: what would happen to its light, to solar storms and to the auroras they bring? Once, for about 70 years, the real Sun came close.
- Watch What If? Lab What if we could travel at the speed of light? Light travels about 300,000 kilometers every second. At that speed you could reach the Moon in 1.3 seconds, but the nearest star after the Sun would still take more than four years. And physics says nothing with mass can ever quite reach light speed. Explore why.
- Watch What If? Lab What if you found a meteorite? Meteorites are pieces of space rock that survived a fiery trip through Earth's air. Most come from asteroids, a few from the Moon or Mars, and many are older than any rock ever found on Earth. Imagine finding one: learn the clues scientists look for, what is inside, and why the right first step is to tell a grown-up and ask a museum or university.
Explore next
- Watch What If? Lab What if meteor showers happened every night? A few shooting stars streak across any clear night sky, but during a meteor shower you might see dozens an hour. Showers happen when Earth passes through dust left by a comet, which is why they come back on the same dates every year. Imagine a shower every night, and find out what that would take.
- Watch What If? Lab What if you could ride a comet? A comet's center is a dusty ball of ice a few kilometers across, racing around the Sun. In 2014, the European Space Agency's Philae lander touched down on comet 67P, and because the comet's gravity is so weak, it bounced! Imagine riding a comet, then see what a real spacecraft found.
- Watch What If? Lab What if an asteroid struck the Moon? The Moon's craters are a record of space rocks landing over billions of years, and small ones still land there every day. Scientists watch for tiny flashes of light on the Moon and later find the brand-new craters. Explore what happens when a rock hits the Moon, and why the Moon keeps going around Earth as always.
- Watch What If? Lab What if the Sun had no sunspots? Sunspots are darker, cooler patches on the Sun made by strong magnetic fields, and their numbers rise and fall about every 11 years. Imagine a Sun with none: what would happen to its light, to solar storms and to the auroras they bring? Once, for about 70 years, the real Sun came close.
- Watch What If? Lab What if we could travel at the speed of light? Light travels about 300,000 kilometers every second. At that speed you could reach the Moon in 1.3 seconds, but the nearest star after the Sun would still take more than four years. And physics says nothing with mass can ever quite reach light speed. Explore why.
- Watch What If? Lab What if you found a meteorite? Meteorites are pieces of space rock that survived a fiery trip through Earth's air. Most come from asteroids, a few from the Moon or Mars, and many are older than any rock ever found on Earth. Imagine finding one: learn the clues scientists look for, what is inside, and why the right first step is to tell a grown-up and ask a museum or university.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if Earth had no Moon? The Moon's pull stretches Earth's oceans and gives us most of our tides. Take the Moon away in our tide model and see what is left: the Sun still makes tides, but they are less than half as big as the Moon's.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if Earth had two moons? Our Moon goes round Earth in a neat, repeating loop. Add a second moon in our orbit model and watch what changes: the two moons tug on each other as well as on Earth, so their paths start to wobble.
For parents & teachers
What children will learn
- Comets are icy leftovers from the early solar system.
- Near the Sun, comets grow a coma and two tails that point away from the Sun.
- Meteor showers happen when Earth passes through comet dust.
- Astronomers can calculate comets' paths and predict their returns, as Halley did.
Recommended ages: 7 to 17 ยท About 12 minutes
Talk about it
- Why do you think comets surprised people long ago?
- Why would a comet's tail point away from the Sun even when the comet is heading away from it?
- Halley's Comet returns in 2061. How old will you be?
Try at home or in class
- Make a model comet: tie ribbons to a small ball. Hold it in front of a fan (the 'Sun'): the ribbons always stream away from the fan, whichever way you move the ball.
- On the night of a meteor shower, such as the Perseids around August 12, lie back somewhere dark with an adult and count the meteors you see in 15 minutes.
Key vocabulary: comet, nucleus, coma, meteor shower, orbit
Where these facts come from
- Comets: Facts , NASA Science
- Meteors and Meteorites: Facts , NASA Science
- 1P/Halley , NASA Science
- Planetary Defense , NASA Science
Checked, not yet human-reviewed. Last updated October 24, 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.