What If? Lab
What if a house’s heating switched off on a cold night?
On a cold night, a heater keeps a house warm. What if the heater stopped? Watch the house cool down in Olly's lab!
A warm house is always leaking heat into the cold night. If the heating stops, nothing replaces it. In our model, an insulated house at 20 °C on a 0 °C night cools to about 15 °C in 12 hours, and then more and more slowly as it gets closer to the outside temperature.
With its heater off, a house's temperature gap to the outdoors decays exponentially with a time constant τ = C ÷ (U·A). In the model, an insulated house (U = 0.6 W/m²·K, 300 m², 25 MJ/K) has τ = 38.6 h: from 20 °C on a 0 °C night it reaches 14.7 °C after 12 h and 10.7 °C after 24 h. Without insulation, τ shrinks to 11.6 h.
The big question
It is a freezing night. Inside, the house is warm and cozy. A heater keeps it that way.
What if the heater stopped? Would the house get cold right away?
On a winter night, warmth is always slipping out of a house through its walls, roof, windows and floor. Usually a heater puts the warmth back as fast as it escapes, so you never notice.
But heating can stop: a furnace can break down, or a storm can cut the power. In this lab, a house at 20 °C sits in a steady 0 °C night, and the heater switches off. Does the house turn cold in minutes, in hours or in days? And does it cool at a steady rate?
A heated house in winter is in a steady state: heater output equals the heat lost through its envelope. Remove the heater and the house runs on stored heat, the energy held in its air, walls, floors and furniture.
This lab models a house with a 300 m² shell, an average U-value of 0.6 W/m²·K and a heat store of 25 MJ/K, held at 20 °C until its 10 kW heater stops on a night that stays at 0 °C. The question: how does its temperature evolve over the next 48 hours?
Try the experiment
Make a prediction
The heater stops on a freezing night. The house started at 20 degrees. How warm is it after a long night?
The heating stops in a 20 °C house on a 0 °C night. In the model, about how warm is the house 12 hours later?
U = 0.6 W/m²·K, A = 300 m², C = 25 MJ/K, 20 °C inside, 0 °C outside, heater off. What is the model's temperature after 12 hours?
- About 15 °C
- About 0 °C
- Still 20 °C
| Control | In our world | What ifโฆ | Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heater power ยท How much heat the heater can make when it is on. Choose 0 for a power cut. | 10 kW | 0 kW | 0โ20 kW |
| How leaky the walls are ยท How easily heat leaks through each square meter of wall, roof and floor. Insulation makes this number smaller. | 0.6 W/m²·K | — | 0.1โ3 W/m²·K |
| Outside temperature ยท How cold the night is. The model keeps it the same for the whole run. | 0 °C | — | -20โ25 °C |
| Outer surface area ยท All the walls, roof, windows and floor that heat can escape through. | 300 m² | — | 100โ600 m² |
-
Established fact
Heat moves from warm places to cold places, faster when the difference is big.
Heat flows out through a wall faster when the difference between inside and outside is bigger.
Conductive heat flow through a wall is proportional to the temperature difference across it (OpenStax College Physics 2e §14.5).
-
What the model shows
In the model, the house cools fast at first and then more and more slowly.
In the model, with the heater off, the insulated house falls from 20 °C to about 15 °C in 12 hours and about 11 °C in 24.
Model: τ = 38.6 h; T = 14.7 °C at 12 h, 10.7 °C at 24 h, 5.8 °C at 48 h, an exponential approach to 0 °C.
-
What the model shows
In the model, a house with no insulation gets cold much faster.
In the model, a house with no insulation cools to about 7 °C in the same 12 hours.
Model: U = 2 gives τ = 11.6 h and 7.1 °C at 12 h; U = 0.3 gives τ = 77.2 h and 17.1 °C.
-
Established fact
Never use a stove or oven to warm a house.
Ready.gov warns never to heat a home with a gas stove or oven, and to use generators and grills only outdoors.
Ready.gov: generators, camp stoves and charcoal grills only outdoors, at least 20 feet from windows; never a gas stovetop or oven to heat a home (carbon monoxide risk).
With the heating on
With the heater working, the house stays at 20 degrees.
Warmth leaks out all the time. The heater keeps putting it back.
With the heater working, our model house loses heat at about 3.6 kilowatts, all night long. The 10-kilowatt heater switches on and off to hold 20 °C, running about a third of the time.
The house also stores a lot of heat in its air, walls and floors. The model treats it like a giant hot-water bottle holding as much heat as about 6 tonnes of water. That stored heat is what keeps the house warm for a while after the heater stops.
At 20 K of difference, the shell loses Q = U·A·ΔT = 0.6 × 300 × 20 = 3.6 kW, so the 10 kW heater runs 36% of the time. The model lumps the whole house into one heat store, C = 25 MJ/K, comparable to about 6 tonnes of water.
Dividing the store by the shell's conductance gives the time constant τ = C ÷ (U·A) = 25,000,000 ÷ 180 s ≈ 38.6 hours. It sets how quickly the house would cool if the heat input stopped.
Switch the heater off
Now the heater stops. The house starts to cool down.
At first it cools quite fast. Later it cools more and more slowly.
Choose 'power cut' and press play. In the first two hours, the house drops about 1 °C. After 12 hours, a long winter night, it is down to about 15 °C. After a whole day it is about 11 °C, and after two days about 6 °C.
Look at the graph: the line curves. In the first 12 hours the house loses about 5 degrees, but between hours 36 and 48 it loses only about 2. It never quite reaches 0 °C, it just creeps closer and closer.
With P = 0, C·dT/dt = −U·A·(T − T_out), so T − T_out = 20 · e^(−t/τ). The model's run gives 19.0 °C at 2 h, 14.7 °C at 12 h, 10.7 °C at 24 h and 5.8 °C at 48 h. After one time constant (38.6 h) the gap has shrunk by 63%.
The heat loss is proportional to the remaining gap, so it starts at 3.6 kW and shrinks as the house cools. Change U to compare: with no insulation (U = 2), τ = 11.6 h and the house is at 7.1 °C after 12 h; well insulated (U = 0.3), τ = 77.2 h and it is still 17.1 °C.
Why it slows down
Heat moves from warm places to cold places. A big difference makes it move fast.
As the house gets cooler, the difference gets smaller. So the heat leaks out more slowly.
Heat leaks out faster when the inside is much warmer than the outside. At first, the house is 20 degrees warmer than the night, so heat pours out. As it cools, the difference shrinks, so the leak slows down.
In the model, two things slow the cooling: insulation, which slows the leak, and a bigger heat store, which has more warmth to lose. Our model is simple. It gives the whole house one temperature, keeps the night at exactly 0 °C, and leaves out drafts, sunshine, and the warmth that people and appliances give off.
Because heat loss is proportional to ΔT, the decay is exponential, the same mathematics as Newton's law of cooling for a cup of cocoa. The time constant τ = C ÷ (U·A) grows with thermal mass and shrinks with leakier or larger envelopes.
The model's assumptions are strong: one lumped temperature for every room, wall and floor; no air leakage or ventilation; no solar or internal gains; and an outdoor temperature that never changes. Each of these is a real heat flow or a real variation that the single equation leaves out, so its numbers show the shape of the cooling, not a forecast for any real house.
When the heat really goes off
Big winter storms can sometimes stop the heating or the power.
Families can get supplies and flashlights ready. If it gets very cold, people can go to warm places that have power.
Ready.gov, the U.S. government's preparedness website, says a winter storm can last a few hours or several days and can cut off heat and power. It suggests gathering supplies in case you need to stay home for several days without power, with extra batteries for flashlights. If the cold is extreme, it suggests going to a community location that has power, and checking with local officials about warming locations nearby.
It also gives one important safety rule. Never heat a home with a gas stove or oven, and use generators and grills only outdoors, away from windows. They can fill a house with a poisonous gas called carbon monoxide.
Ready.gov (FEMA) notes that winter storms can last from hours to days and cut off heat, power and communications, and that older adults, children, sick people and pets are at greater risk. During an outage it advises going to a community location with power if heat or cold is extreme, and checking with local officials for warming and cooling locations.
Its carbon monoxide guidance is firm: generators, camp stoves and charcoal grills only outdoors and at least 20 feet from windows, never a gas stovetop or oven to heat a home, and battery-backed CO detectors on every level. The model's lesson fits the advice: insulation and stored heat buy time, but not unlimited time.
Amazing facts
-
A house stores lots of heat in its walls and floors, like a giant hot-water bottle.
In the model, the house stores about as much heat for each degree as 6 tonnes of water, which is why it takes many hours to cool.
The model's heat store is 25 MJ per kelvin, roughly the heat capacity of 6 tonnes of water; the model uses it to stand for a medium-weight house.
-
In the model, the house never gets quite as cold as outside.
In the model, the house gets closer and closer to the outside temperature but never quite reaches it, even after two days.
Exponential decay approaches its limit asymptotically: after 48 h the model house is still 5.8 °C, and after five time constants (about 8 days) the gap would be under 1% of its start.
-
Some homes have alarms that warn about a dangerous gas.
Ready.gov advises putting carbon monoxide detectors with battery backup on every level of a home.
Ready.gov recommends carbon monoxide detectors with battery backup in central locations on every level, since CO is colorless and odorless.
Words to know
- heat loss
- the heat escaping from a warm place to a colder one
- insulation
- material that slows down heat moving through walls, roofs and floors
- time constant
- the time it takes something cooling (or warming) this way to close about two thirds of its temperature gap
- exponential decay
- a change that slows down as it goes, because each step is a fixed fraction of what is left
- carbon monoxide
- a poisonous gas with no color or smell; generators, grills and stoves can give it off
Discovery challenge
-
The heater stops. How does the house cool?
With the heating off, how does the house's temperature change in the model?
With P = 0, the model house's temperature over time is best described as…
- Fast at first, then more slowly
- At exactly the same speed all night
- Not at all
Show the answer
Fast at first, then more slowly
Fast at first, then more slowly, as the difference gets smaller.
Fast at first, then slower: the heat leak shrinks as the house gets closer to the outside temperature.
…an exponential decay toward the outdoor temperature, with τ = 38.6 h.
-
Which house gets cold fastest?
Which model house cools fastest when the heating stops?
Which model house has the shortest time constant?
- The house with no insulation
- The well insulated house
- They all cool at the same speed
Show the answer
The house with no insulation
The house with no insulation. Warmth leaks out of it fastest.
The house with no insulation: it is about 7 °C after 12 hours, against about 15 °C insulated.
The uninsulated one: τ = C ÷ (U·A) = 11.6 h at U = 2, against 38.6 h at U = 0.6.
-
What should never be used to warm a house?
According to Ready.gov, what should never be used to heat a home?
Which heat source does Ready.gov say must never be used to heat a home during an outage?
- A gas stove or oven
- Warm clothes and blankets
- A community warming location
Show the answer
A gas stove or oven
A stove or oven. It can make a dangerous gas.
A gas stove or oven: it can fill a home with carbon monoxide and cause fires and burns.
A gas stovetop or oven, because of the carbon monoxide risk; generators and grills belong outdoors, at least 20 feet from windows.
Experiments to try
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if a house had no insulation? Heat always leaks out of a warm house into the cold outside. Insulation in the walls and roof slows that leak down. In our model, an insulated house on a freezing day needs its heater only about a third of the time. Take the insulation away and the same heater runs nonstop, and the house still cools to about 17 °C.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if your cocoa went in a flask? A mug of hot cocoa cools fast: in our model it drops from 80 °C to 60 °C in under 12 minutes. Pour the same cocoa into a vacuum flask and it takes about 100 minutes. Find out how a flask blocks the three ways heat escapes.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if winter were much colder? Heat leaks out of a house faster when it is colder outside. In our model, an insulated house kept at 20 °C needs about 86 kilowatt-hours of heat a day when it is 0 °C outside. Drop the outside to −20 °C and the gap doubles, so it needs twice as much: about 173 kilowatt-hours.
- Watch What If? Lab What if there were no electricity for a day? Electricity reaches your home through a giant network called the grid. Sometimes storms or faults cut it off for a while. Imagine a whole day without it: what happens to the lights and the fridge, how does the grid get electricity to you, and how do hospitals keep working when it stops?
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if a house had a tiny heater? A warm house is always leaking heat into the cold outside. A heater keeps it warm only if it can put heat back as fast as it leaks out. In our model, a 10-kilowatt heater keeps a leaky house at 20 °C on a freezing day. Swap it for a tiny 3-kilowatt heater, and the house slowly cools until it finds a new balance.
Explore next
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if a house had no insulation? Heat always leaks out of a warm house into the cold outside. Insulation in the walls and roof slows that leak down. In our model, an insulated house on a freezing day needs its heater only about a third of the time. Take the insulation away and the same heater runs nonstop, and the house still cools to about 17 °C.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if your cocoa went in a flask? A mug of hot cocoa cools fast: in our model it drops from 80 °C to 60 °C in under 12 minutes. Pour the same cocoa into a vacuum flask and it takes about 100 minutes. Find out how a flask blocks the three ways heat escapes.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if winter were much colder? Heat leaks out of a house faster when it is colder outside. In our model, an insulated house kept at 20 °C needs about 86 kilowatt-hours of heat a day when it is 0 °C outside. Drop the outside to −20 °C and the gap doubles, so it needs twice as much: about 173 kilowatt-hours.
- Watch What If? Lab What if there were no electricity for a day? Electricity reaches your home through a giant network called the grid. Sometimes storms or faults cut it off for a while. Imagine a whole day without it: what happens to the lights and the fridge, how does the grid get electricity to you, and how do hospitals keep working when it stops?
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if a house had a tiny heater? A warm house is always leaking heat into the cold outside. A heater keeps it warm only if it can put heat back as fast as it leaks out. In our model, a 10-kilowatt heater keeps a leaky house at 20 °C on a freezing day. Swap it for a tiny 3-kilowatt heater, and the house slowly cools until it finds a new balance.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if a battery had more voltage? A battery's voltage is how hard it pushes electric current around a circuit. Swap a 3-volt battery for a 9-volt one in our model and the same two bulbs carry three times the current, and each one uses nine times the power. Find out why, and why a real bulb can burn out on too much voltage.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if a battery wasted energy as heat? A battery's label tells you how much energy it stores. But on the way from the battery to a device, some energy always turns into heat in the wires and electronics. In our model, a 60-watt-hour battery runs a 10-watt lamp for 6 hours when nothing is lost. If 30% is lost as heat, the lamp goes dark after 4 hours 12 minutes.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if a battery were old and tired? Every battery has a little resistance inside it. A fresh battery has hardly any, but as a battery gets worn out, that inside resistance grows. In our model, four bulbs side by side glow at full brightness on a fresh 3-volt battery. Make the battery old and tired, and watch what happens to the bulbs and to the battery itself.
For parents & teachers
What children will learn
- Heat flows from warmer to cooler places, faster across a bigger temperature difference.
- Without a heat source, a house cools quickly at first and then more slowly (exponential decay).
- Insulation and stored heat slow cooling; the time constant C ÷ (U·A) captures both.
- Safe, practical steps for winter outages, including never heating a home with a stove or oven.
Recommended ages: 11 to 17 ยท About 20 minutes
Talk about it
- Why does the house cool more slowly as the night goes on?
- Which rooms in your home do you think would get cold first if the heating stopped, and why?
- What could a family get ready before a winter storm, and why?
Try at home or in class
- A grown-up fills two jars with the same amount of warm tap water (not hot). Wrap one in a towel. Measure both with a kitchen thermometer every 10 minutes for an hour and plot the readings: do the lines curve like the model's?
- Find your home's carbon monoxide detectors together and check whether they have battery backup.
Key vocabulary: heat loss, insulation, time constant, exponential decay, carbon monoxide
Where these facts come from
- College Physics 2e, 14.5 Conduction , OpenStax, Rice University
- Winter Weather , Ready.gov (FEMA, U.S. Department of Homeland Security)
- Power Outages , Ready.gov (FEMA, U.S. Department of Homeland Security)
- Calculus Volume 1, §6.8 Exponential Growth and Decay (Newton's law of cooling) , OpenStax
Checked, not yet human-reviewed. Last updated October 26, 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.