Skip to content
PlayOwl

What If? Lab

What if a switch were left open?

Click! A switch turns a light on and off. How does it do that? Open the switch in Olly's lab and see!

A switch is a little gate in a circuit. Closed, it lets electric current flow all the way around the loop. Open it in our model and the loop has a gap: the current drops to zero and every bulb goes dark at once, however the bulbs are wired.

Current flows only around a closed path. In the model, two 3 Ω bulbs in series on a 3 V battery carry 0.50 A; open the switch on the battery's wire and the current falls to 0 A everywhere. Wired in parallel the bulbs draw 2 A between them, and the same open switch still stops it all, because every path runs through it.

Explore

The big question

Press a switch and the light comes on. Press it again and the light goes off.

What does a switch really do? What happens when it is left open?

You flick switches every day: for lights, fans, toys and flashlights. But what is actually happening inside when you do?

Electricity can only flow when it has a complete loop to travel around, from the battery, through the wires and bulbs, and back again. In this lab, a battery lights two bulbs, with a switch in the wire. What do you think happens to the bulbs if the switch is left open?

A circuit carries a steady current only around a closed conducting path. A switch is a device that opens or closes that path on purpose: two metal contacts that either touch or are pulled apart.

This lab places a switch in the wire next to the battery and asks what opening it does to two bulbs wired in series, and then to the same bulbs wired in parallel, where each bulb has its own path back to the battery.

Try the experiment

Make a prediction

Two bulbs glow in a loop. Olly opens the switch. What happens to the bulbs?

Two bulbs glow in a loop with a switch next to the battery. If the switch is left open, what happens to the bulbs?

Two bulbs in series glow on a 3 V battery. The switch beside the battery is opened. What do the bulbs do?

  • Both bulbs go dark
  • Only the bulb next to the switch goes dark
  • Both bulbs keep glowing
What you can change
ControlIn our worldWhat ifโ€ฆRange
Switch ยท Closed lets the current flow around the loop. Open leaves a gap, so no current can flow anywhere. 1 0 0โ€“1
Bulbs ยท How many bulbs are in the circuit. Does the switch still turn them all off? 2 bulbs — 1โ€“4 bulbs
How the bulbs are joined ยท Series: one path through every bulb. Parallel: each bulb has its own path. Mixed: bulb 1 first, then the others side by side. 0 — 0โ€“2
Battery voltage ยท How hard the battery pushes the current around the loop. This lab starts at 3 volts. 3 V — 0โ€“12 V
  • Established fact

    Electricity only flows around a loop with no gaps.

    Electric current flows only around a complete circuit. A switch opens or closes the circuit on purpose.

    A steady current needs a closed conducting path; in a series loop the current is the same everywhere (Kirchhoff's current law, OpenStax College Physics 2e §21.3).

  • What the model shows

    In the model, opening the switch makes both bulbs go dark at once.

    In this model, opening the switch drops the current from half an ampere to zero, and both bulbs go dark together.

    Model: two 3 Ω bulbs in series on 3 V carry 0.50 A (1.5 W); with the switch open, 0 A and 0 bulbs lit.

  • What the model shows

    In the model, the switch turns off side-by-side bulbs too.

    In this model, the switch is on the wire every path shares, so it turns off parallel bulbs as well.

    Model: in parallel the battery supplies 2 A (1 A per branch); the open switch on the shared line still gives 0 A.

  • Established fact

    Some switches in a home turn off by themselves to keep wires safe.

    Circuit breakers and fuses open a circuit automatically when too much current keeps flowing.

    Fuses and circuit breakers act as automatic switches that open when a sustained current exceeds safe limits (OpenStax College Physics 2e §20.6).

Switch closed

The switch is closed. That means the loop has no gaps.

The battery pushes electricity around the loop. Both bulbs glow.

With the switch closed, the loop is complete. In the model, a 3-volt battery pushes a current of half an ampere around it, through the first bulb and then the second.

The two bulbs share the battery's push, 1.5 volts each, so each one glows at about a quarter of the brightness one bulb alone would have. Over the model's 12-second run, the pair uses 18 joules of energy.

Closed, the switch adds no resistance in the model. Two 3 Ω bulbs in series give 6 Ω, so Ohm's law gives I = 3 V ÷ 6 Ω = 0.50 A. Each bulb drops 1.50 V and dissipates 0.75 W, which is 25% of the 3 W one bulb alone would draw from the same battery.

Total power is 1.5 W, and over the model's 12-second run the circuit uses 18 J. The model treats each bulb as a fixed resistance and compares brightness by electrical power.

Leave the switch open

Now Olly opens the switch. There is a gap in the loop.

Both bulbs go dark at the same time. Even the bulb far from the switch!

Open the switch and both bulbs go out together. The current meter drops to zero, and the energy counter stops climbing. The bulb on the far side of the circuit goes dark just as fast as the one next to the switch.

Now choose 'parallel', so each bulb has its own path. With the switch closed they glow brightly, 1 ampere each. Open the switch again: both still go dark. In this model the switch sits on the wire that every path shares.

Open, the switch removes the connection between the battery and the rest of the network, so no closed path remains. The model's battery current falls from 0.50 A to 0 A, the bulbs lit from 2 to 0, and the power from 1.5 W to zero.

In parallel, the closed circuit draws 2 A in total (1 A per bulb at the full 3 V, 6 W). Opening the switch still gives 0 A, because both branches return through the switch on the battery's line. To control one bulb alone, a switch would have to sit on that bulb's own branch; this model does not offer that layout.

Why it happens

Electricity needs a full loop, like a race car needs a full track.

An open switch is like a bridge that has been lifted. Nothing can get across the gap.

Inside a switch are two pieces of metal. Metals let electric charge move through them easily; scientists call them conductors. When the switch is closed, the metal pieces touch and the current flows across.

When the switch opens, the pieces pull apart and leave a gap, and the current cannot cross it. Because the loop is broken in one place, the current stops everywhere in the loop at once, not just near the switch. Our model is simple: its battery never runs down and its bulbs never burn out.

Metals are conductors: some of their electrons are free to move through the material. Insulators such as glass, rubber and plastic bind their charges so tightly that they move as much as 10²³ times more slowly (OpenStax). An open switch leaves a gap the current cannot cross, so its resistance is effectively infinite.

In a single loop there are no junctions, so Kirchhoff's current law makes the current the same everywhere: if it is zero at the switch, it is zero in every bulb. The model's limits: fixed bulb resistance, a battery that never runs down, and an ideal switch with no resistance when closed.

Switches all around you

Lights come on the moment you press the switch.

Homes also have special switches that turn off by themselves if too much electricity flows. They help keep wires safe.

When you flick a switch, the light comes on straight away. That is not because electrons race from the switch to the bulb. In a copper house wire, the electrons themselves drift along at less than half a millimeter per second. The push travels down the wire far faster, at a big fraction of the speed of light.

Homes also have automatic switches called circuit breakers. If too much current keeps flowing, the breaker opens the circuit by itself, so the wires do not overheat. Only grown-ups should ever touch a home's breaker box.

OpenStax works out that electrons in a 12-gauge copper household wire carrying 20 A drift at about 4.5 × 10⁻⁴ m/s, while the electrical signal moves at around 10⁸ m/s: closing a switch sends a change in electric field along the wire, which is why lights come on as soon as a switch is flicked.

Fuses and circuit breakers open a circuit automatically when a sustained current exceeds safe limits; a breaker is a restorable switch, and the one OpenStax shows trips when a bimetallic strip bends as it overheats. At high voltages a spark can ionize the air in a breaker's gap and keep current flowing; large breakers in power-distribution systems use insulating gas, even jets of gas, to blow the spark out.

Amazing facts

  • When you press a light switch, the light comes on right away.

    The electrons in a house wire creep along at less than half a millimeter per second, but the light still comes on the moment you flick the switch.

    In a 12-gauge copper wire carrying 20 A, electrons drift at about 4.5 × 10⁻⁴ m/s; the signal moves on the order of 10¹² times faster, about 10⁸ m/s (OpenStax).

  • Rubber and plastic around wires keep the electricity inside.

    The rubber and plastic covering a charger cable are insulators: they keep the electric charge from escaping out of the metal wires inside.

    Insulators such as rubber, plastic and glass hold their charges so tightly that charge moves through them up to 10²³ times more slowly than through conductors (OpenStax).

  • Some switches turn off all by themselves to keep wires safe.

    A circuit breaker is a switch that opens by itself when too much current keeps flowing, and it can be switched back on afterward.

    In one circuit-breaker design, a bimetallic strip bends when overheated and releases a spring that pulls the contacts apart; unlike a fuse, which melts, the breaker can be reset (OpenStax).

Words to know

circuit
a complete loop that electric current can flow around
switch
a part that opens or closes a circuit, turning the current off or on
open circuit
a circuit with a gap in it, so no current can flow
conductor
a material, such as a metal, that lets electric charge move through it easily
insulator
a material, such as rubber or plastic, that does not let electric charge move through it easily
circuit breaker
an automatic switch that opens a circuit when too much current flows

Discovery challenge

  1. The switch is open. What happens to the bulbs?

    Two bulbs are in a loop. What happens to them when the switch is left open?

    Two bulbs are in series with a switch. When the switch is opened, what happens to the bulbs?

    • They all go dark
    • Only the closest bulb goes dark
    • They glow brighter
    Show the answer

    They all go dark

    They all go dark, because the loop has a gap.

    They all go dark: the gap stops the current everywhere in the loop.

    The current drops to zero everywhere, so they all go dark: in a single loop the current is the same at every point.

  2. What are the insides of a switch made of?

    What material are the two contacts inside a switch made of, so current can flow when they touch?

    The contacts that touch inside a closed switch must be made of…

    • Metal, which lets electricity through
    • Rubber
    • Glass
    Show the answer

    Metal, which lets electricity through

    Metal! Electricity can move through metal easily.

    Metal: metals are conductors, so current flows across when the contacts touch.

    …a conductor such as metal; rubber and glass are insulators.

  3. Which switch turns off by itself when too much electricity flows?

    Which kind of switch opens by itself when too much current keeps flowing?

    Which device acts as an automatic, restorable switch that opens when a sustained current is too high?

    • A circuit breaker
    • A light bulb
    • A battery
    Show the answer

    A circuit breaker

    A circuit breaker. It helps keep the wires safe.

    A circuit breaker opens the circuit by itself so the wires do not overheat.

    A circuit breaker; a fuse does the same job but must be replaced once it melts.

Experiments to try

Explore next

For parents & teachers

What children will learn

  • Electric current flows only around a complete circuit.
  • A switch opens or closes a circuit; an open switch stops the current everywhere in the loop.
  • Metals are conductors and rubber and plastic are insulators.
  • Circuit breakers and fuses are automatic switches that protect wires from too much current.

Recommended ages: 4 to 17 ยท About 15 minutes

Talk about it

  • Why does the bulb far from the switch go dark just as fast as the one next to it?
  • In your home, why can one lamp be switched off while other things keep working?
  • Why do you think breaker boxes are only for grown-ups to touch?

Try at home or in class

  • With a grown-up, look at a battery flashlight. Find the switch, then trace with your finger the loop the current takes from the battery, through the bulb and back. Talk about where the gap opens when the switch is off.
  • Stand in a circle holding a loop of string, passing a knot around to show the current. Let one person open their hands to be the switch, and watch the knot stop for everyone. Never play with wall sockets, plugs or breaker boxes.

Key vocabulary: circuit, switch, open circuit, conductor, insulator, circuit breaker

Where these facts come from

  1. College Physics 2e, 20.1 Current , OpenStax, Rice University
  2. College Physics 2e, §20.6 Electric Hazards and the Human Body , OpenStax
  3. College Physics 2e, 18.2 Conductors and Insulators , OpenStax, Rice University
  4. College Physics 2e, §21.1 Resistors in Series and Parallel , OpenStax
  5. College Physics 2e, §21.3 Kirchhoff's Rules , OpenStax

Checked, not yet human-reviewed. Last updated October 26, 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.