What If? Lab
What if birds forgot how to build nests?
Birds build nests for their eggs and babies. What if they forgot how? Some birds don't build nests at all! Let's find out with Olly.
Nests keep eggs and chicks safe from predators and the weather, and birds build them in amazing ways: from twigs, grass, mud, hair and even spider silk. Imagine every bird forgetting how to build one. Then meet the birds that already manage without, from cliff-ledge murres to emperor penguins.
A 2026 study of more than 7,400 bird species found that domed nests mainly reduce predation, while cavity nests buffer harsh climates. This thought experiment removes nest-building and asks what eggs and chicks would face, and how species that lay on bare rock, on gravel or on their own feet solve the same problems.
The big question
A robin builds a cup of grass for its eggs. Many birds build nests.
What if all the birds forgot how? Where would they put their eggs?
Every spring, birds get busy carrying twigs, grass and moss to build nests. A nest is a cradle: a place to lay eggs, keep them safe, and raise the chicks that hatch.
What if every bird suddenly forgot how to build one? In this thought experiment, you will find out what nests do, discover the amazing range of nests birds make, and meet some birds that already lay their eggs without a nest at all.
Birds build nests of many kinds, from simple scrapes to woven domes and cavities. Nests protect eggs and young, and research links different designs to concealment from predators and to protection from harsh climates.
This thought experiment imagines all birds losing the ability to build. It draws on a 2026 global analysis of nest types and on species that already reproduce without a built nest, to ask what nests do and what the alternatives cost.
Explore the idea
Make a prediction
Where does an emperor penguin dad keep the egg warm?
Emperor penguins don't build nests. Where does the father keep the egg?
How do male emperor penguins incubate without a nest?
- On his feet, under a fold of skin
- In a tree
- In a hole in the ice
-
Established fact
Nests keep eggs and chicks safe.
Roofed nests mainly hide eggs from predators, and nests in tree holes and burrows help keep the temperature steady.
Domed nests track predation risk and cavity nests track harsh climates across more than 7,400 bird species (2026).
-
Established fact
Some birds don't build nests at all.
Murres lay on bare cliff ledges, emperor penguins hold the egg on their feet, and cuckoos use other birds' nests.
Ledge laying, foot incubation and brood parasitism are established nest-free strategies.
-
An idea scientists discuss
Without nests, many eggs might be in danger.
If birds forgot how to build nests, many eggs might be eaten or get too hot or cold.
Nest loss might raise egg mortality, most for species that rely on enclosed nests.
-
Established fact
Birds build nests to protect their eggs and babies.
Birds build nests to protect their eggs and chicks.
Nests protect eggs and offspring; a roofed nest such as the sora's also shelters the birds from the weather (Summit Metro Parks).
-
Established fact
Nests with roofs help hide eggs. Nests in holes keep them warm or cool.
Domed nests mainly reduce the risk from predators, while nests in tree holes and burrows protect eggs from big temperature swings.
Across more than 7,400 species, domed nests track predation risk and cavity nests track harsh, variable climates (Academia Sinica and University of Maryland, 2026).
-
An idea scientists discuss
Without nests, more eggs might be found by hungry animals.
Without nests, more eggs might be eaten by predators or harmed by heat and cold.
Losing nests might raise egg predation and thermal stress, especially for species that rely on enclosed nests.
-
Established fact
Hundreds of sociable weavers can share one nest.
Sociable weavers in the Kalahari build enormous shared nests that house weaver families by the hundreds and stay cool in summer and warm in winter.
Sociable weaver colonies house families by the hundreds; the nests stay cool in summer and warm in winter, and other species use spare chambers (Cornell Lab, Living Bird, 2019).
-
Established fact
Hummingbirds use stretchy spider silk in their nests.
Hummingbirds build tiny nests from plant down, lichens and spider silk; the silk stretches as the chicks grow.
Ruby-throated hummingbird nests are plant down bound with spider silk; their pliable walls stretch as the nestlings grow (Cornell Lab of Ornithology).
-
Established fact
A murre lays its egg on a bare rock ledge.
Common murres don't build a nest; they lay a single, very pointed egg on a cliff ledge above the sea.
Murres lay one egg directly on a cliff ledge, sometimes ringed with pebbles cemented by guano; the egg is very pointed at one end (All About Birds).
-
Established fact
Penguin dads keep the egg warm on their feet.
Emperor penguin fathers balance the egg on their feet under a fold of feathered skin for about two months, eating nothing.
Male emperor penguins incubate on their feet under a brood pouch for about two months while fasting (National Geographic).
-
Established fact
Cuckoos let other birds raise their babies.
Female common cuckoos don't build nests; each lays 12 to 22 eggs a season in other birds' nests.
Common cuckoos are brood parasites, laying 12–22 eggs a season, each in a different host nest (RSPB).
-
An idea scientists discuss
Birds might find new ways to keep their eggs safe.
Without nests, birds might guard their eggs more, hide them in cracks, or carry them, like emperor penguins.
Nest loss might favor alternative strategies, such as crevice laying, constant attendance or brood parasitism; which would work for which species is speculation.
What nests do
A nest keeps eggs safe. A roof can hide them from hungry animals.
A nest in a tree hole keeps eggs warm on cold nights and cool on hot days.
Nests protect eggs and chicks. In 2026, scientists in Taiwan and the United States looked at the nests of more than 7,400 kinds of birds. They found that nests with a roof, called domed nests, mainly help hide eggs and chicks from predators. Nests in tree holes and burrows mainly protect against harsh weather, because wood and soil keep the temperature steady.
Some nests do both. The sora, a marsh bird, weaves a roof of living cattails and sedges over its nest, which shelters the birds from the weather.
A team from Academia Sinica's Biodiversity Research Center and the University of Maryland (Global Ecology and Biogeography, June 2026) analyzed nest types in more than 7,400 species, about 74 percent of known birds. In passerines, domed nests were more common where predator diversity was higher, consistent with a role in concealment and blocking access. Cavity nests were more common in dry regions with large temperature swings, where tree trunks and soil insulate eggs and nestlings.
The authors note that artificial nest boxes often insulate less than natural cavities, which matters for conservation as climates change.
A world without nest builders
Without nests, eggs might roll away or get too cold.
Hungry animals might find them more easily. Baby birds would have no cozy home.
If every bird forgot how to build a nest, eggs would have to be laid on the bare ground, on branches or on rock. Without a cup to hold them, eggs might roll off. Without a roof or a hole, they might be easier for predators to spot, and harder to keep at the right temperature.
Chicks would have no soft, safe place to grow up. Birds might have to spend more time guarding and warming their eggs. Some might manage; many might struggle.
Losing nest-building would remove the concealment benefits of domed nests and the thermal buffering of cavities that the 2026 study links to predation and climate. Eggs on exposed surfaces might suffer higher predation and greater temperature stress, and parents might need to compensate with more attentive incubation and defense.
How severe this would be would vary by species: birds already adapted to nest-free laying would be little affected, while those relying on enclosed nests in harsh climates or predator-rich areas might fare worst. These are inferences, not predictions.
Many kinds of nest
Birds make cups, platforms and holes. They use twigs, grass, hair and even spider silk!
Sociable weavers build one giant nest that hundreds of birds share.
Bird nests come in three main kinds: cups, platforms and cavities, or holes. Canada geese make cups on the ground, grebes build floating platforms, and wood ducks nest in tree holes. Cerulean warblers bind bark, grass and hair together with spiderwebs. A ruby-throated hummingbird's nest is only about 5 centimeters (2 inches) across, made of plant down held together with spider silk; its walls stay stretchy, so the nest grows with the chicks.
In Africa's Kalahari Desert, sparrow-sized sociable weavers build enormous shared nests like apartment buildings, housing weaver families by the hundreds. The nests stay cool in summer and warm in winter.
Summit Metro Parks naturalist Ben Mullaly describes three main nest types: platforms (grebes), cavities (wood ducks) and cups (Canada geese, on the ground). Materials range widely: cerulean warblers bind bark, grass and hair with spiderwebs, and ruby-throated hummingbirds hold thistle or dandelion down together with spider silk, camouflaging the outside with lichen; the pliable walls stretch as the chicks grow (Cornell Lab of Ornithology).
The most spectacular builders are sociable weavers of the Kalahari, whose communal nests house families by the hundreds. Robert Thomson (University of Cape Town) calls them ecosystem engineers: the nests stay cool in summer and warm in winter, other birds such as pygmy falcons occupy spare chambers, and the birds' droppings enrich the soil beneath the tree.
Birds that skip nests
Some birds don't build nests! Murres lay one egg on a bare cliff ledge.
Emperor penguin dads hold the egg on their feet. Cuckoos lay eggs in other birds' nests.
Some birds already manage without building a nest. Common murres lay a single egg straight onto a cliff ledge above the sea; the egg is very pointed at one end. Killdeer just scratch a shallow dip in bare ground and lay their eggs there.
Emperor penguin fathers keep the egg off the ice by balancing it on their feet under a warm fold of feathered skin, for about two months, without eating. And female common cuckoos skip all the work: they lay their eggs in other birds' nests and let those birds raise their chicks.
All About Birds notes that common murres lay their single egg directly on a cliff ledge, sometimes arranging pebbles that become cemented by guano, and that the egg is very pointed at one end. Killdeer nests are shallow scrapes about 3 to 3.5 inches across; parents lure predators away with a broken-wing display.
Emperor penguin males incubate the egg on their feet under a brood pouch for about two months while fasting (National Geographic). Common cuckoos are brood parasites: a female lays 12 to 22 eggs a season, each in a different host's nest, removing one host egg each time (RSPB). Each species has replaced the nest with another solution.
Amazing facts
-
Killdeer pretend to be hurt to protect their eggs.
A killdeer leads predators away from its nest by pretending to have a broken wing.
Killdeer are among the best-known users of the broken-wing display, feigning injury to lure predators from the nest (All About Birds).
-
Killdeer decorate their nests with light-colored bits.
After laying eggs, killdeer often add rocks, bits of shell and sticks to their ground nest, and they tend to choose light-colored ones.
Killdeer add light-colored items to their scrapes; an experiment offering light and dark sticks confirmed the preference (All About Birds).
-
Even cheetahs climb onto weaver nests to sunbathe!
Cheetahs have been seen climbing trees to lie on the domed roofs of sociable weaver nests and soak up the sun.
Cheetahs sometimes sprawl over the roofs of sociable weaver nests to bask (Cornell Lab, Living Bird).
Words to know
- nest
- a place a bird makes or chooses to lay its eggs and raise its young
- incubate
- to keep eggs warm so they can hatch
- predator
- an animal that hunts and eats other animals
- cavity
- a hole, such as a hollow in a tree, used as a nest
- brood parasite
- a bird that lays its eggs in other birds' nests for them to raise
- communal nest
- one big nest shared by many birds
Discovery challenge
-
What do nests with roofs mostly help with?
According to the 2026 study, what do domed (roofed) nests mainly protect against?
Which pressure did the 2026 study link most strongly to domed nests?
- Predators finding the eggs
- Rain filling the nest
- Eggs getting too big
Show the answer
Predators finding the eggs
Roofs help hide eggs from hungry animals.
Predators: roofs help hide eggs and block access.
Predation risk, tracking predator diversity.
-
Where does a murre lay its egg?
Where does a common murre lay its egg?
What is a common murre's nest site?
- On a bare cliff ledge
- In a tree hole
- In a woven basket
Show the answer
On a bare cliff ledge
On a bare rock ledge by the sea.
Straight onto a cliff ledge above the ocean.
A bare cliff ledge, sometimes with pebbles cemented by guano.
-
Which bird lays its eggs in other birds' nests?
Which bird doesn't build a nest but uses other birds' nests instead?
Which species is a brood parasite?
- The common cuckoo
- The emperor penguin
- The sociable weaver
Show the answer
The common cuckoo
The cuckoo!
The common cuckoo lays its eggs in other birds' nests.
The common cuckoo, laying 12–22 eggs a season in host nests.
-
How many sociable weavers can live in one nest?
About how many sociable weaver families can share one big nest?
What is the scale of a sociable weaver colony?
- Hundreds
- Just one
- Exactly two
Show the answer
Hundreds
Hundreds!
Weaver families by the hundreds.
Families by the hundreds, in one communal structure.
Experiments to try
- Watch What If? Lab What if there were no spiders? Spiders around the world catch an estimated 400 to 800 million tons of prey every year, mostly insects. They also spin some of the toughest materials in nature. Imagine a world with no spiders: what would happen to all those insects, and what would we lose?
- Watch What If? Lab What if animals could change color like an octopus? Octopuses and cuttlefish change the color and texture of their skin in the blink of an eye, using thousands of tiny color cells. They use it to hide and to send signals. Imagine if many more animals could do it: who would hide better, what would they say with color, and what would it cost them?
- Watch What If? Lab What if cows could not digest grass? A cow's own body can't break down the tough stuff in grass. Tiny microbes living in its huge stomach do it instead, and the cow chews its food twice to help them. Imagine those helpers gone and follow what might change.
Explore next
-
Watch
Animal
Sociable weaver
The sociable weaver is a sparrow-sized bird of the dry savannas of southern Africa. Whole colonies, sometimes hundreds of birds, build and share one enormous thatched nest with many separate rooms. It is among the largest nests built by any bird.
-
Watch
Animal
Emperor penguin
The emperor penguin is the largest penguin in the world. It lives around Antarctica, and it is the only animal that breeds during the dark, freezing Antarctic winter. Fathers keep the egg warm on their feet for about two months, huddled together against the storms.
- Watch What If? Lab What if there were no spiders? Spiders around the world catch an estimated 400 to 800 million tons of prey every year, mostly insects. They also spin some of the toughest materials in nature. Imagine a world with no spiders: what would happen to all those insects, and what would we lose?
- Watch What If? Lab What if animals could change color like an octopus? Octopuses and cuttlefish change the color and texture of their skin in the blink of an eye, using thousands of tiny color cells. They use it to hide and to send signals. Imagine if many more animals could do it: who would hide better, what would they say with color, and what would it cost them?
- Watch What If? Lab What if cows could not digest grass? A cow's own body can't break down the tough stuff in grass. Tiny microbes living in its huge stomach do it instead, and the cow chews its food twice to help them. Imagine those helpers gone and follow what might change.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if elephants talked with very low sounds? Elephants really do talk with very low rumbles, some too low for people to hear. Turn the pitch down in our sound model and see what changes about the wave, then find out how far real elephant calls can carry.
- Watch Try it What If? Lab What if fish had no swim bladder? Most bony fish carry a gas-filled pouch called a swim bladder. It makes the fish almost exactly as heavy for its size as the water around it, so it can stay at one depth without sinking or floating up. Use a floating-and-sinking model to see what happens when the gas is taken away.
- Watch What If? Lab What if there were no decomposers? Bacteria, fungi, earthworms and millipedes break down dead leaves, wood and dead plants and animals, and give their nutrients back to the soil. National Geographic calls them Earth's cleanup crew. Imagine a world without them, and follow what might pile up, what might run short, and who does the work.
For parents & teachers
What children will learn
- Nests help protect eggs and chicks from predators and from heat and cold.
- Birds build many kinds of nests from many materials.
- Some birds reproduce without building a nest, using other strategies.
- Scientists compare thousands of species to discover what nests are for.
Recommended ages: 5 to 17 · About 15 minutes
Talk about it
- If you were a bird, what kind of nest would you build, and why?
- Why might a murre's pointed egg be useful on a cliff ledge? How could scientists test your idea?
- What do you think is the hardest thing about raising chicks without a nest?
Try at home or in class
- Try building a small nest from twigs, grass and string that can hold three marbles. Tip it gently. Do the marbles stay in?
- Watch birds in a park or yard in spring (from a distance, never touching nests). Note any birds carrying nest materials and what they carry.
Key vocabulary: nest, incubate, predator, cavity, brood parasite, communal nest
Where these facts come from
- A Major Discovery in Bird Architecture: How Predators and Climate Shape Different Nest Designs , Biodiversity Research Center, Academia Sinica
- Why do birds make nests? (Ben Mullaly, 2020) , Summit Metro Parks, Ohio
- In Africa, Sociable Weavers Build a Nest of Many Uses (Hugh Powell, Living Bird, 2019) , Cornell Lab of Ornithology, All About Birds
- Common Murre: Life History , Cornell Lab of Ornithology, All About Birds
- Killdeer: Life History , Cornell Lab of Ornithology, All About Birds
- Emperor Penguin , National Geographic
- Emperor Penguin , Two Oceans Aquarium, Cape Town
- Cuckoo , RSPB
- Ruby-throated Hummingbird: Life History (nesting) , Cornell Lab of Ornithology, All About Birds
Checked, not yet human-reviewed. Last updated October 26, 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.
Picture credits
- Photo: Charles J. Sharp, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons · source · license
- Photo: Alan D. Wilson, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons · source · license
- Photo: Dafna Ben nun, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons · source · license
- Photo: Charles J. Sharp, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons · source · license